If it's lock picking the judge's door open: find the tab with the most resistance when you click and drag the paperclip over it. Let go so it sits as close to the top as possible.
Another tab will then be the most resistant, do the same thing so they are both as close to the top as possible. If you push too high they will both release.
Find the next tab with the most resistance and do the same thing, until all of them are done. I had to restart several times not because I was clicking on the wrong tab but because I pushed it too far up.